How to Measure Etsy Success like a CEO (Even after One Sale)

How to Measure Etsy Success like a CEO (Even after One Sale)

The smell of your morning coffee still lingers in the air as your daily task list looms.

Gotta answer those customer questions…
Better update those old listings…
What about that new Instagram photo challenge?

Oh and making some beautiful things. You know – the whole reason your shop exists.

Thank goodness for that coffee!

It’s hard work running a small business, especially when your Etsy shop needs so much marketing and promotion to keep making sales. Sometimes it feels like you do more “business” than “making”.

So what I’m about to suggest might sound a little scary. We’re going to go even deeper into “business”.

The level of strategy and KPIs.

Key performance indicators? Really??!

Don’t worry, these aren’t the “awkward closed-door meetings with your boss” kind of KPI. These are the kind that focus how you measure your shop’s performance and tell you when to have a celebratory drink.

If you don’t know what success should look like, how will you know when you get there? How will you know when to crack that champagne?!

You need to figure out what your “success metrics” are, first.

In this post:

How’s the business going?

When I say, “How do you measure success in business?” what’s the first thing that comes to mind?

Money! Money! Money!

After all, business is all about financial success.

But measurement isn’t just about observing your current situation. It’s about understanding how you got there and where you will (or can) go next.

So while every single Etsy shop could just use “profit margin” and “net revenue” to measure their success—and they would technically get an answer—there’s no major benefit in knowing that you had a 30% profit margin if you’ve only had 5 sales.

That doesn’t tell you whether you’re likely to get a 6th, 7th or 100th sale. (Because I think most of you would agree that 5 sales is satisfying but not success.)

Side note: it’s actually great to know that you pulled off a 30% profit margin on 5 sales, because it tells you that your pricing system is working! But it doesn’t tell you that your business is working.

Instead, choose a handful of metrics to watch or calculate on a regular basis, that give you the wider picture of your business:

  • finances
  • growth
  • customers & customer satisfaction
  • your own satisfaction (yes, you’ve actually got to enjoy this thing!).

Choose metrics that suit your situation

Different Etsy shops have different goals. These goals depend on the stage of your shop, the type of products you sell, the way your visitors like to buy and even your personal lifestyle goals.

Shops in different situations need different metrics to show their whole picture of success.

Here are some examples to start you thinking about what might be best for your business.

Just starting out

If your shop is brand spankin’ new, there’s no point wasting your time calculating difficult financial metrics. Instead, focus on visitor growth and watch where they come from.

   Raw visitor numbers 

Segment by marketing channel

Full time Etsy shop

Running a full time Etsy shop is the same as running any business, so it’s time to be your own Chief Financial Officer! Focus on how well you’re converting visitors into sales, whether you’re earning enough money to be sustainable and growing your profit margin.

   Conversion rates
   Revenue
   Profitability

Segment by customer types / target audiences

Selling wedding rings (long research phase)

If you sell big ticket items or products that customers spend a lot of time researching or comparing, then you shouldn’t necessarily expect a high conversion rate. Instead, focus on showing repeat visits and good visitor engagement, which indicates you’re performing well in their pre-purchase phase.

   Engagement rates
   Visitor frequency

Consider just showing your best performing/most popular marketing channels and/or products. This isn’t cheating! It’s focusing on what’s important to your business and avoiding “noise” that might impact the averages.

Plenty of free time & want a part-time Etsy shop

If you have the time to spend on growing your Etsy business slowly & steadily, then track metrics that reflect consistent growth in visitors and money coming through the door. You have time to improve things like conversion rates and profit margins without rating your business as “less successful” for you.

   Increases in visitors over time
   Revenue 

Segment by customer types and marketing channels

Already have a full-time job & need to make Etsy worthwhile before going “full time”

Plenty of people are in this boat! This is the tricky stage where Etsy doesn’t bring in quite enough money to quit your day job, but you need more time to grow your business to get there. How on earth will you fit everything in!??

Here you need to focus on efficiency and making the most of what you already have. Maximise the value of the time you spend marketing by increasing conversion rates and how much buyers purchase in one go.

   Conversion rates
  Avg. transaction values

Segment by marketing channels

  Profitability

Segment by customer types and marketing channels

It's time to be your Etsy shop's own Chief Financial Officer! How do you measure success?Click To Tweet

Whoa! How do I measure these money metrics??

If you’re paying attention, you’ll notice that I’ve got a lot of hard hitting business metrics in there – dropping terms like average transaction value and profitability. And you’ll know that those can be hard to measure in Google Analytics, for an Etsy shop. But that highlights an important part of this “success defining” process: it’s not about the tool, it’s about your business!

Define the metrics that really matter. Work out how to measure them later. (Even if that means doing it by hand.)

Put it all together & watch your progress

BONUS WORKSHEET: Grab a free worksheet for the 6 steps below as part of my 4 week course. (It’s lesson 5.) Get started now!

1. Write it down

List your success metrics on a piece of paper (TIP: go landscape!).

2. Decide on your frequency

How often will you check in? Weekly, monthly, quarterly, 6 monthly or annually? Can you automate some of these numbers in a dashboard or report so you can check more often? Write the dates across the top of the page (or do it as you go if you’re checking weekly).

TIP: The bigger your shop, the more frequently you should check your success metrics.

3. Check your benchmarks

For each metric, work out your number for today, based on how often you’ll be checking that metric. If you’ve decided that it’s a monthly metric, then record the value for the past month. Write the date and the values down the page.

4. Set targets

At the far side of the paper, set a 12-month target against every metric. If you have no idea, make a guess (you can change it later). A wild guess is better than no target at all!

 

5. Record your progress

At your decided check-in dates, record the value of each of your metrics. How has it changed from last time? Is it better or worse? Calculate a percentage change if you like.

If the change is significant or nowhere near where you expected, that’s when you jump into your detailed reports to find out why and what to do about it.

6. Change with the times

The metrics you focus on WILL change over time! As your shop moves through the stages of growth, you switch up your product lines or discover new types of customers, then your ideal success metrics will also change.

Don’t forget to review and renew them at least annually.

You can change your targets too. If they’re completely unrealistic or way too easy, set new ones. Just remember to leave yourself a challenge 😉

Is this all I need to measure?

No!

These “success metrics” are not the only numbers to look at! They’re just the numbers that give you the best picture of your business success (and potential success) at any point in time. You should absolutely look at a whole range of metrics on a regular basis to make day-to-day decisions and make sure your business is on the right track.

(I’ve made you some dashboards for that.)

When I say, “Don’t measure your success by your revenue or profit” when you’re just starting out, that does NOT mean you shouldn’t pay attention to your revenue and profit at all! Just don’t judge your progress by it right now.

Find your success metrics

Figuring out what success should look like for you is an important part to running your Etsy shop like a real business. Because it is. And the more business-like you make it, the more efficient and successful you have the chance to be, leaving you more time to do what’s really important…

Making beautiful things.

I’d love to know what you think your success metrics are, including your targets if you’d like to share them below!

Got Google Analytics installed but don’t quite… get it?

Stop watching numbers and start making decisions with my free 4 day course (with lifetime access). It’s easy, at your own pace, and designed to help creative entrepreneurs like you, get your head around Google Analytics.

Get Access Now!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.